skip to main content skip to footer

OUR FOOD

Small Plates

*all homemade spreads served with warm pita bread*

Tzatziki

Pairs Well With Riesling

Greek Yogurt, Cucumber, Dill, Garlic Topped With Crisp Cucumber Slices

(4oz.) $8.00 I (8oz.) $10.00

Hummus

Pairs Well With Rosé

Chick Peas, Lemon, Fresh Garlic

(4oz.) $8.00 I (8oz.) $10.00

Spanakopita

11.00

Pairs Well With Chardonnay

Layers of Crisp Phyllo Dough Filled With Fresh Spinach and Feta Cheese

Greek Fries

10.00

Pairs Well With Sauvignon Blanc

Hand cut Fries, Topped With Feta Cheese and Oregano

Dolmades

9.00

Pairs Well With Pinot Grigio

Tender Vine Leaves Wrapped Into Little Rolls And Stuffed With Rice And Fresh Herbs

Tirokafteri

Pairs Well With Rosé

Spicy Feta, Roasted Red Pepper, Extra Virgin Olive Oil, With a Dash of Heat

(4oz.) $9.00 I (8oz.) $11.00

Greek Meze Sampler

Tzatziki, Tirokafteri, and Hummus

(4oz.) $20.00 I (8oz.) $26.00

Bavarian Pretzel

10.00

Pairs Well With Pinot Grigio

Served With Artisan Mustard Dipping Sauces

Handcut Fries

7.00

Gourmet Salads and Soups

Village Salad

Pairs Well With Sauvignon Blanc

Barrel Aged Feta, Fresh Tomatoes, Cucumbers, Bell Peppers, Shaved Red Onions, Imported Olives, Drizzled With Extra Virgin Olive Oil and Oregano

Regular 11.00 | Large 14.00

Avgolemono Soup

7.00

Pairs Well With Chardonnay

Yiayia's Special Greek, Lemon, Chicken Soup topped With Orzo Pasta and Served With Crusty Baguette Slices

Caesar Salad

Pairs Well With Pinot Grigio

Crisp Romaine Hearts, Croutons, Traditional Caesar Dressing and Shaved Parmesan Cheese

Regular 10.00 | Large 13.00

Pita Sandwiches

Served with lettuce, tomatoes, red onion and tzaziki sauce

Carved Beef/lamb Gyro

12.00

Pairs Well With Syrah, Merlot, Cabernet

Seasoned Beef and Lamb, Slow-Roasted and Carved Off The Rotisserie, Wrapped In Warm Pita Bread

Village Salad Pita

10.00

Pairs Well With Sauvignon Blanc

Ripe Tomatoes, Cucumber, Green Bell Peppers, Chopped Red Onions, Barrel Aged Feta, Imported Greek Olives

Carved Chicken Gyro

13.00

Pairs Well With Syrah, Merlot, Cabernet

Seasoned Chicken, Slow-Roasted and Carved Off The Rotisserie, Wrapped In Warm Pita Bread

Falafal Sandwich

11.00

Pairs Well With Sauvignon Blanc

Finely Ground Chickpeas, Onions, Parsley, Garlic, and Spices; Deep Fried Into Semi Circles, Wrapped In Warm Pita

Pizzettes

Regular

14.00

Pairs Well With Sangiovese

Thin Crust Pizza Topped with a Classic Homemade Marinara and Fresh Mozzarella Cheese

Prosciutto Arugula Balsamic

17.00

Pairs Well With Pinot Grigio and Sangiovese

Thin Crust Pizza Topped with Sliced Prosciutto, Crispy Arugula, and Drillzed with a Balsamic Glaze 

Margherita

15.00

Pairs Well With Red Blend

Fresh San Marzano Tomato, Fresh Mozzarella, Topped with Pecorino Romano, Extra Virgin Olive Oil, Fresh Basil and Italian Seasoning

Artisian Charcuterie Box

Choose From 

Meat:
Prosciutto |Sweet Salciccia Secca| Hot Salciccia Secca | Sweet Soppressata | Hot Coppocola | Sweet Coppocola | Chorizo

Cheese:
Manchego | Brie | Fresh Mozzarella |Barrell Aged Feta | Asiago

*All Served With Imported Olives and Fruit Preserves*

The Day Tripper

27.00

Choose 1 Cheese & 1 Meat

The Fire Islander

53.00

Choose 3 Cheeses & 3 Meats

The Weekender

39.00

Choose 2 Cheeses & 2 Meats

Desserts

Shuga Pies (Exclusively at FIV)

5.00

We know it will be Love at First Bite!  These delicious freshly made flavored Cake Sandwiches  from The Shuga Pie Shop are now available online and for in person ordering. We suggest to preorder your favorite flavors if you need 8 or more, since we will have a limited supply. 

Flavors:

Death by Chocolate

Cookies and Cream

Funfetti

Birthday Cake

 Vanilla Crumb

The Original Chocolate Cake/Vanilla Cream

More flavors to come. Ask us about a new flavors available. 

Packages and Promos

Date Night Package

72.00

*Comes with 1 Large Spinach Pie, 1 Large Village Salad, 1 Choice of Hummus, Tzaziki or Tirokafteri, 2 Gyros, 1 Bottle of FIV Sangria

*Available for Pick Up Tues-Fri 3:30-7:30*

Extra Sides

Extra Tzaziki

1.50

Perfect for dipping your fries or gyro into!

Extra Feta Cheese

2.50

Side of Falafel

6.00

Extra Pita

1.00

Perfect for dipping into our homemade spreads or enjoying with our cheese box!

Side of Gyro Meat

6.00

TAPS LOCAL BEER / HARD CIDER / WINES /SANGRIA

16 OZS.  BEER / CIDER

6 OZS. WINES

12 OZS. SANGRIA

1 Brooklyn Brewery Hazy Pulp Art (6.5%)

9.00

3 Catskill Devil's Path IPA 7.3%

9.00

5 FIV SANGRIA

10.00

7 5 Boroughs Pilsner 5.0%

9.00

8 Jamesport Vineyards Red Blend

9.00

A ripe blend of 55% Cabernet Franc, 17% Merlot, 17% Petit Verdot & 11% Cabernet Sauvignon produce a perfect example of the powerful 2015 vintage dark tones & structured tannins.

10 Montauk Brewery Driftwood Ale 5.0%

9.00

12 Blue Point Toasted Lager 4.8%

9.00

14 Great South Bay Brewery Blond Ambition 4.7%

9.00

2 Brooklyn Brewery Summer Ale 6%

9.00

4 Fire Island Vines Rose

10.00

6 McKenzie's Pineapple Cider (6.0%)

9.00

.

7A McCalls Sauvignon Blanc 2020

10.00

9 Brklyn Keg & Latern Golden Ale 6.0%

9.00

11 DOC'S ORIGINAL DRAFT Cider 5.0%

9.00

13 MacKenzies Black Cherry Cider 5.2%

9.00

CANS

FREE TIME TROPICAL WATERMELON HARD SELTZER

7.00

Add a Vodka Floater for $3.00 more

LIV Vodka Fizz

7.00

(Lime, Lemonade, Watermelon)

GSB Lemonaide Selzter

7.00

Guinness Draught Stout 4.2%

7.00

Smooth and Creamy

WHITE WINE

ONLY AVAILABLE BY THE BOTTLE

FIV Reisling (2018) BOTTLE + BY THE GLASS

32.00

This wine is luscious and crisp with vibrant fruits. Its flowery aroma blends layers of honeydew, melon, and peach with bursts of aromatic jasmine. Its soft acidity blends with sweetness, all of which adds to its sipping pleasure

Martha Clara Sauvignon Blanc (2019) Limited Supply

34.00

Showing notes of green apple and lime zest on the nose and offering flavors of yellow delicious apple creaminess on the palate with subtle hints of nutmeg

Osprey Dominion Reserve Chardonnay 2020

32.00

100% Barrel fermented and posseses aromas of ripe tropical fruit with barrel notes of vanilla and spice.

SUHRU Pinot Grigio (2019) Gold Medal Winner

34.00

Made from 100% Pinot Grigio fruit, this white wine was fermented and aged entirely in stainless steel tanks. Pale straw yellow in color with an earthy aroma and hints of lemon zest of the nose, it has notes of granny smith apple and bosc pear

Millbrook Chardonnay (2019)

34.00

Aromas of clementine, tangerine, custard and toasted almond highlight well-balanced fruit and acid levels. The soft, silk flavors have a nice minerality with notes of Honeycrisp apple and caramel that linger on the round finish.

McCall Sauvignon Blanc 2020

34.00

Crisp,lively, and elegant, style after the French Sancerre. This wine was made from estate-grown and sustainably farmed vines. Hand harvest grapes in stages to naturally elicit the full range of flavors, from bright citrus to wildflowers. 

RED WINE

ONLY AVAILABLE BY THE BOTTLE

Laurel Lake Cabernet Sauvignon (2015)

36.00

A substantial wine bursts on the palate with flavors of ripe berries. This is a well- balanced wine with an intense aroma and powerful velvet finish

Osprey Red Blend (2018)

30.00

A blend of wines from premium red grapes. Aromas of blackberry, spicy cherry, chocolate, light eucalyptus and a hint of sweet oak. Grapes used are 42% Cabernet Franc, 26% Cabernet Sauvignon, 23% Merlot, and 11% Pinot Noir

Bedell Cabernet Franc (2017)

38.00

Purple Flowers, focused and powerful, with juicy and ripe flavors and silky tannins, aged in neutral oak

Osprey Dominion Spice Wine

34.00

Base with cloves, nutmeg and cinnamon.

FIV Pinot Noir (2016) BOTTLE + BY THE GLASS

38.00

This Pinot Noir is our most popular red and is aged 18 months in a 100% French oak barrel. It is smooth, rich and fleshy with a complex array of cherry, plum and blackberry

Bedell Malbec (2018)

38.00

Sultry dark fruits, exotic, enticing, supple and ripe flavors. Oak aged and hand harvested

McCall Estate Pinot Noir (2015)

36.00

Sustainably farmed, hand harvested, and aged  12 months in French Oak to add layers of complexity and enhance the expression of our unique terroir; this wine is versatile & enjoyable on any occasion. This Pinot balances dark cherry, strawberry, vanilla, and toast. Meduim weight, well structured, & silky, it's worth the wait. 

McCall Estate Merlot (2014)

34.00

Sustainably farm, hand harvested, and nine months in French Oak barrels. Adding layers of complexity, giviving it an intensely coloredwine showing notes of plum, blackberry and cherry alongside vanilla and tobacco. Only 695 cases produced.

ROSÉ WINE

ONLY AVAILABLE BY THE BOTTLE

Bedell Rose (2020)

34.00

Elegant, coastal, dry and aromatic with vibrant acidity. 60% Merlot, 30% Cabernet Franc, 10% Cabernet Sauvignon

Summer In a Bottle Rosé (2020)

50.00

A lovely balance between the fresh fruit, fine tannins, good minerality and graceful acidity. 40% Merlot, 22% Chardonnay, 12% Cabernet Sauvignon, 7% Gewürztraminer, 6% Cabernet Franc, 4% Pinot Meunier, 4% Pinot Blanc, 3% Riesling, 2% Sauvignon Blanc

Bellafina Sparkling Pink Moscato

32.00

This Rose' is a soft and sweet wine, displaying fresh aromas and flavors of melon, peach and red berries, perfect for all cuisine or any occasion.

MCall Majorie Rosé (2020)

34.00

This Rose' is made from sustainable grapes, hand-picked on Long Island's North Fork. Crushed with the grape skins promptly removed to impact just a touch of pink color. Fermented in stainless steel tanks to bring you a natural glass of wine with the perfect balance of aromatics and ripe red fruit. Named for Marjorie McCall, founder Russ McCall's mother. This wine is light and dry with notes of raspberries, rose petals, and red fruit

Bedell Sparkling Rose' 2020

40.00

Small batch production of a unique blend of  75% Cabernet Sauvignon and 25% Merlot. Estate grown and fermented with indigenous yeast.

Tasting Flight

Tap Tastings

19.00

Mix and match any 4 of the taps and build your perfect flight!

Pre- Selected Wine Flight

22.00

We're highlighting these 4 fine wines this month

- McCall Merlot

- Bedell Rose'

-  Osprey Dominion Chardonnay

- FIV Pinot Noir

Sparkling Wine

Bedell Sparkling Rose' 2020

40.00